Mullaney Tire & Car Care Center

310 Broad St
Matawan, NJ 07747 US
3 Reviews
Write a Review

BMW repair and service in Matawan, NJ.

Providing expert BMW repair and maintenance for motorists in Monmouth County since 1964. Our BMW service center offers full diagnostics and repairs for your vehicle.

For over 50 years we've been servicing the areas of Matawan, Aberdeen, Morganville, Marlboro, Old Bridge, Freehold, Colts Neck, Holmdel, Sayreville, South Amboy, Keyport with expert BMW maintenance and repair. We employ BMW factory trained technicians and utilize the ISTA Next diagnostic system to diagnose, repair, program and recode the systems in your BMW.

We are a one stop BMW specialty shop that takes pride in outstanding customer service and an unique ability to articulate information to our clients in both a technical and non-technical manner. We work with you to help provide a honest solution to whatever automotive needs you may or may not be aware of on your vehicle. We communicate with you in a manner unlike any other shop, and work with you to meet your needs as well as the needs of the car.

Our BMW service include, but are not limited to:

  • Factory Scheduled Maintenance
  • Electrical Systems
  • Tune-Ups
  • Transmission
  • Tire Inspection
  • Engine
  • Brakes


  • After Hours Drop-Off
  • Cable TV
  • Courtesy Car Wash
  • Customer Lounge
  • Free Wifi
  • Magazines
  • Refreshments
  • Shuttle Service
  • Transit Accessible
  • Walkable Area
  • Weekend Hours


  • I have been using Mullaney Tire and Car Care for several years and have nothing but the highest opinion of them. My first encounter with Joe and company was when I was having a problem with my 2010 5-series BMW. The dealer quoted $6,000 to fix it, Joe fixed it for less than 1/3 the price. After that they have been the only shop I would take either of my BMWs to. I have had tires replaced, tune-ups and general check-ups done and every time I am totally impressed by Joe's knowledge and willingness to explain things. Joe has also provided excellent references to other service providers for services they don't perform, for me this was the replacement of a plastic rear window in an M3 convertible.

    Joe Sr. is also great! Several times he has given me a ride home went I couldn't wait for my car. Joe Sr. is a great guy to talk with.

    Lastly, I am currently relocating to Memphis, and Joe has been very helpful in helping me find other service providers there. Hopefully they will be as helpful as Joe has been, and based on my experiences with Joe, I am sure they will be.

    Charles S.
  • Top class service from a highly knowledgeable and professional repair facility. I contacted Joe from Mullaney's regarding technical and mechanical problems with my BMW; I had previously phoned around several repair facilities before dealing with Joe. His interest in my case along with a knowledgeable and assertive attitude impressed me from the start and I decided to go with his service. I was glad I did. Joe and Craig kept me informed during every process in repairing the car and all was explained accordingly. Overall the customer service and perfectionism was impeccable and the issues with the car were sorted and repaired. I have every faith in their service and can't recommend them enough and will be back to them for any maintenance or advice needed in the future.

    Liam on November 2, 2015
  • Integrity, customer focused and extremely competent is how I would describe this second generation tire and car care center. I have been going to Mullaney's for 2 years now getting both my BMW and Ford Explorer serviced there.

    Mullaney's is not just a car and service center it is a fully fledged mechanics. I started off bringing my Ford there after the dealership prices were getting too expensive (on parts that never seemed to be covered on the manufacturer warranty) but I was always concerned about whether an independent car center would be able to provide good workmanship when compared with a dealership.

    After a few visits with the explorer for more detailed works I realized how good they were and brought my BMW in for some needed repairs. I compared the pricing between Mullaney's and BMW and found that Mullaney's usually came in around 50% less (give or take 10% depending on the jobs and parts needed). They are also a BMW certified shop and parts are genuine BMW sourced from a local BMW dealer.

    The 50% cost difference is about the same when compared to Ford (parts also sourced from local Ford dealership). Mullaney's also identified components on my Ford that should have been changed within my warranty coverage or service plan but the work just wasn't carried out.

    It took me around 2 years to put Mullaney's through its paces first giving them minor work and then stepping up to more complex tasks and comparing pricing with my dealerships. In June of this year I let my warranty on the Explorer lapse for the first time ever instead opting to defer to Mullaney's. I never really got my moneys worth on the Ford Warranty because so many things just weren't covered.

    The warranty on my BMW ends this December and I will be deferring all works to Mullaney's since I know now that I can trust their workmanship and the fact that they'll provide genuine parts and won't rip me off.

    There are not many things harder than finding a good honest car center but I couldn't be happier with these people hence the shining review!

    Stephen P.
  • Joe and his crew consistently offer high quality service. I own a 2007 335xi with high miles. These guys have all the necessary BMW diagnostic tools in order to properly diagnose and fix any problem that I have brought them. If you have a BMW and need anything from regular maintenance to turbo replacement and major engine repair, do not go to the BMW service center. Got to Mullaney's. The work will be done faster and for significantly less money than a BMW service center. These guys love a challenge and they actually want your business. The owner regularly attends continuing education seminars in order to best service all new technologies found in today's cars. They have a fully trained BMW service tech on staff as well. I love my car and these folks are the only ones I trust with it.

    Jeremy S. Matawan, NJ, via Yelp on January 30, 2015
  • Joe has been taking care of my 335i since I purchased it at the end of 2011, as well as my Accord, for several years before that. He tells it like it is and I wish the world was as honest as him. It will be hard to find an honest and capable mechanic like him when I move out of state. If you are looking for a fancy shop like in the stealerships, this isn't the place for you. If you care for getting the job done right, go right in!

    Muhammad E. Englishtown, NJ, via Yelp on November 14, 2014
  • I have been bringing my cars to Joe since I started driving and have had nothing but excellent experiences with Joe and his team of mechanics. Joe is a professional in every sense of the word. I truly trust his expertise with my car. He is always honest and fair recommending the least expensive, but safest option for repairs and maintenance. I highly recommend that everyone bring their vehicle to Mullaney Tire for maintenance and repair.

    Nicole K. Hoboken, NJ, via Yelp on March 3, 2014
  • Good people. Mullaney combines great service with the friendly caring of a local business. They care, and it shows in every aspect of the operation.

    Richard D. Middletown, NJ, via Yelp on September 4, 2013

Awards & Affiliations

Bosch ServiceBosch Service

3 Reviews

  • Jeremy
    Jeremy5 years ago

    Joe and his crew always deliver high quality service at reasonable prices. I love my car and I trust them with everything from regular maintenance to engine work. These guys are the best. They have all the BMW diagnostic tools and a BMW service tech employee. Don't pay dealer service rates. Go to Mullaney Tire & Car Care Center and say hi to Joe for me. You will be happy you did.

    2007 BMW 335 xi
    Was this review helpful?
  • JS
    JS10 years ago

    Honest and great to deal with. I wouldn't bring my foreign car to anyone else in the area but Mullaney Tire & Car Care Center.

    Was this review helpful?
  • John S.
    John S.13 years ago

    These guys are great. They were very easy to deal with and not stuffy or pushy like my local dealer. No pressure and the job was done right with OEM parts and very fair labor. They also repaired an issue I had been bringing my car to the dealer for to no avail. Not just good with my car, but overall good to deal with. Highly recommend Mullaney Tire & Car Care Center.

    Was this review helpful?